Hanafi vs Shafi'i Zakat: Jewelry, Gold & Ushr Rules
Side-by-side rulings on worn jewelry, gold Nisab, agricultural Ushr, and whether Zakat is due on a child's wealth—Hanafi vs Shafi'i.
The fundamental obligation of Zakat is agreed upon by all Muslims. However, the classical schools of Islamic jurisprudence (Madhabs) have valid scholarly differences regarding exactly which assets are subject to Zakat and under what conditions. The two most widely followed schools globally are the Hanafi and Shafi'i schools.
Ready to calculate your Zakat?
Our calculator is built on authentic Hanafi rulings to help you determine your exact obligation.
| Zakat Issue | Hanafi School | Shafi'i School |
|---|---|---|
| Personal Jewelry | Zakat is obligatory on all gold and silver, including jewelry worn daily or kept for occasions, provided it reaches the Nisab. | Jewelry intended for personal, permissible use is exempt from Zakat. It is considered an item of personal use, similar to clothing. |
| Nisab Threshold (Gold vs Silver) | Contemporary scholars mandate using the Silver Nisab (612.36g) because it is currently lower in value, benefiting the poor. | Wealth is generally not mixed to reach Nisab. Cash is measured against the Gold Nisab, unless specifically tied to silver. |
| Agricultural Produce (Ushr) | Ushr is due on all produce of the earth cultivated for a purpose, regardless of whether it is storable or perishable, and regardless of quantity. | Ushr is only due on crops that are staple foods and can be stored. Not due on vegetables/perishable fruits. Must reach Nisab of 5 Wasqs. |
Conclusion
Both schools are valid interpretations of the Quran and Sunnah. Islamic finance experts generally recommend that laypeople consult a local, trusted scholar and follow one school consistently to avoid "fatwa shopping" (picking the easiest ruling in every scenario).